REVIEW POTPOURRI: Kenneth Roberts

Peter Catesby Peter Cates

Kenneth Roberts

Kenneth Roberts

Kennebunk’s Kenneth Roberts (1885-1957) wrote the historical novel Boon Island in 1956. Boon Island is a ledge 300 by 700 feet in the Atlantic Ocean, 14 miles south of Kennebunkport and, since 1811, has the tallest lighthouse in New England.

The novel is based on the December 1710, shipwreck of the Nottingham from Greenwich, England, when it was blinded during a northeaster after 137 days at sea, and the crew’s struggle for survival against the ravages of the freezing sub zero temperatures, no food and its own dog eat dog human nature impulses.

The first person narrator Miles provided one telling description:

“I hoped that when the northeaster blew itself out, the sea would grow calm, but it didn’t. When the wind swung, it backed into the northwest and west, meaning that bad weather had only temporarily abated. We were free of driving snow and rain, but breakers still roared deafeningly on the north and west. They pounded less on the south and east, but still they pounded, throwing off manes of white foam. The wind seemed colder than on the night we were wrecked.”

Another Roberts novel Northwest Passage was made into a truly classic 1940 film starring Spencer Tracy, Robert Young and Walter Brennan.

Roberts also was known for his activities on behalf of dowsing. Finally, during his writing career, he wore out several copies of Roget’s Thesaurus.

Best book of heroes

A 1958 anthology Good Housekeeping’s Best Book of Heroes and Heroines has chapters from books of such authors as Carl Sandburg (Lincoln), Dorothy Canfield Fisher (Paul Revere), and Helen Keller (autobiography).

The selections that interested me the most were those on how Daniel Boone (1734 – 1820) outsmarted the Shawnees while in their captivity; and how Walter Reed (1851-1902) figured out that yellow fever was caused by mosquitoes, not through contact with victims of the fever.

Will and Ariel Durant

Will and Ariel Durant’s 11 volume The Story of Civilization has sold millions of sets through its introductory offerings to members joining Book of the Month Club. The books lend themselves best to browsing due to the 800 or more pages in each volume yet are written in a very interesting narrative style leading to compulsive reading .

The fifth volume, The Renaissance, tells of the number of good hospitals in Italy, starting with one opened in Siena in 1305 and “famous for its size and services.” Milan and Venice soon followed with highly competitive ones; Florence had 35 hospitals during the 1400s. Most all of them were models of architecture and adorned with art on their walls. Generous support came from the public and private benefactors within the ranks of both the church and nobility.

When Martin Luther visited Italy in 1511, he happily noted “the excellent food and drink, careful attendants, and learned physicians…beds and bedding are clean.”

REVIEW POTPOURRI: Moritz Moszkowski

Peter Catesby Peter Cates

Moritz Moszkowski

Moritz Moszkowski

My first exposure to the music of the early 20th century Polish composer Moritz Moszkowski (1854-1925) came via a WQXR radio broadcast of an out of print recording on the Concert Hall label from the early ‘50s of his Piano Concerto from pianist Hans Kahn with the very underrated Walter Goehr conducting the Netherlands Philharmonic. As I was then a teenager, around 1967, and insatiably eager to hear as much classical music as possible, WQXR was then one of the most well known all classical stations and a favorite source even though only heard on its AM frequency in Maine after dark.

There was a richly melodic eloquence in the work that enthralled me. What was frustrating was the record was out of print and no other recording of the piece was available until pianist Michael Ponti recorded a rather dull performance during the early ‘70s.

Then about 25 years ago, I found the Kahn LP in a used record store, in Wethersfield, Connecticut, for one dollar in very good condition. Since then other pianists have tackled it but I haven’t heard any of them, except for a charming concert performance of the last two movements from the Romanian pianist Raluca Stirbat via Youtube.

The Serenata is a nice transcription for tenor, violin and orchestra with English lyrics of a solo piano piece by the composer and, despite acoustic fidelity, very persuasively performed by the John McCormack/Fritz Kreisler team.

Selvin

Selvin’s Novelty Orchestra – Dardanella; My Isle of Golden Dreams. Victor 18633, ten-inch acoustic shellac.

Dardanella was a hit for Paul Whiteman’s orchestra during the early ‘20s and has a nicely done charm of its own so characteristic of 1920s dance music. The Selvin performance is not quite as rhythmic as Whiteman but has a sweetly phrased lyricism, as does My Isle of Golden Dreams.

Roy Acuff

Roy Acuff – Pins and Needles; We Live in Two Different Worlds. Columbia 36856, ten-inch 78, recorded mid-’40s.

Roy Acuff

Two selections from a founding father of country and western music, Roy Acuff, are typical of the heartbreak of so many love ballads that Acuff, Hank Williams, and others recorded in Nashville starting over 75 years ago. Acuff was a truly skilled singer who put together a very good string band for collaborative purposes.

Jo Stafford

Jo Stafford – A Friend of Yours; On the Sunny Side of the Street. Capitol 199, ten-inch 78 from 1945.

Adi Adios Amigo; Make Love to Me. Columbia 40143, ten-inch 78, from 1954.

Jo Stafford

Jo Stafford’s Capitol sides from when she had broken away from Tommy Dorsey’s band to begin her solo career featured her very intelligently vocalized performances of the rich Great American Songbook standards being written for the film industry in Holly­wood. A Friend of Yours was composed by the team of Johnny Burke and James Van Heusen who provided dozens for Bing Crosby and Frank Sinatra while Sunny Side of the Street, penned by Jimmy McHugh and Dorothy Fields, has been recorded by multiple artists.

The 1954 Columbia record featured typical novelty songs of the ‘50s that other singers for that label such as Doris Day and Rosemary Clooney were recording when Mitch Miller was in charge.

Stafford’s husband Paul Weston provided his unfailingly high quality arrangements.

Ray Noble

Ray Noble

Ray Noble – By the Light of the Silvery Moon; While My Lady Sleeps. Columbia 36479, recorded mid-’40s, ten-inch 78.

By the time Ray Noble’s Orchestra was recording in this country during the post World War II years, his dance arrangements didn’t have the same degree of exquisite elegance that the 1930s Victors from London did. This particular Columbia was good, just not quite in the same class.

Ella Fitzgerald

Ella Fitzgerald

Ella Fitzgerald

Ella Fitzgerald – A Kiss Goodnight; Benny’s Coming Home on Saturday. Decca 18713, ten-inch 78, recorded early 1940s.

Ella Fitzgerald was another truly skilled singer of the Great American Songbook and devoted albums to the creations of George Gershwin, Jerome Kern and Johnny Mercer and others during the ‘50s and ‘60s for the Verve label. Like Stafford, Sinatra and Peggy Lee, she broke away from the confinement of big band contracts to breathe more freely and forge an independent singing career during the post World War II renaissance of the vocalists. These two selections had her blessedly precise timing and phrasing with Randy Brooks’s classy arrangements.

Carmen Cavallaro

Carmen Cavallaro – Miami Beach Rhumba; Cancion del Mar. Decca 24706, ten-inch 78, recorded 1949.

Both of these Cavallaro performances are highly pulsating examples of Latin-American pop music of the ‘40s and ‘50s at its rhythmic best.

Alvino Ray

Alvino Rey – Mama Blues; Midnight Masquerade. Capitol 390, recorded 1947, ten-inch 78.

Alvino Rey had his own orchestra during the big band era but was more distinguished for developing an early type of electric guitar known as the sono­vox. I found the two selections here to be rather bland but I do consider him an important figure with this string instrument. Later he worked with Lawrence Welk’s chief music director George Cates (no relation), Elvis Presley on his Blue Hawaii soundtrack, jazz bandle.

REVIEW POTPOURRI: Celebrating our independence

Peter Catesby Peter Cates

John Dos Passos

Celebrating Independence Day, I found the following paragraph in the first chapter of the 42nd Parallel, a 1937 novel by John Dos Passos (1896-1970):

“U.S.A. is the slice of a continent. U.S.A. is a group of holding companies, some aggregations of trade unions, a set of laws bound in calf, a radio network, a chain of moving picture theatres, a column of stock-quotations rubbed out and written in by a Western Union boy on a blackboard, a public library full of old newspapers and dogeared history books with protests scrawled on the margins in pencil. U.S.A. is a set of bigmouthed officials with too many bank accounts. U.S.A. is a lot of men buried in their uniforms in Arlington Cemetery. U.S.A. is the letters at the end of an address when you are away from home. But mostly U.S.A. is the speech of the people.”

Dos Passos had a unique gift for combining actual slices of history, similar to news reels, with his fictitious characters in his various novels. He was a committed socialist during his younger years but then switched to a conservative world view after a friend of his was cold-bloodedly murdered by Stalin’s assassins during the Spanish Civil War.

Duster

Episode 7 of the current season of the Max TV series Duster, in its recreation of the 1970s, has a depiction of the reclusive multi-millionaire Howard Hughes (1905-1976) who has paid a million dollars for the tape of former President Richard Nixon (1913-1994) authorizing the 1972 Watergate burglary of the Democratic headquarters. While the depiction of the transaction is fictitious, other aspects in the episode are historically correct – those being Hughes depicted as delusional, totally unkempt with long hair and beard and yet a germaphobe who insists that all guests wash their hands at least four times.

Not depicted was Hughes lashing out at former Maine Senator Owen Brewster (1888-1961) during a 1947 Congressional hearing when the Senator tried to unsuccessfully back him into a corner.

Very highly recommended for its intelligent scripting and credible character development.

Giulio Setti

Saint-Saens: Samson and Delilah – Dawn now Heralds the Day (L’Aube qui Blanchit); Gounod: Romeo et Juliette-Prologue. Giulio Setti conducting the Metro­politan Opera Chorus and Orchestra, Victrola Red Seal 4152, ten-inch 78, recorded between late ‘20s and early ‘30s.

Giulio Setti (1869-1938) worked in opera houses in Italy, Egypt, Germany and Argentina before arriving at the Metropolitan Opera House in 1908 as a gifted chorus master.

The above 78 showcases his ability to draw very eloquent ensemble music making on both excerpts. In 1935, Setti returned to Italy.

Eddie Fisher

Eddie Fisher – Lady of Spain; and Outside of Heaven. RCA Victor 20-4953, ten-inch 78, recorded 1952.

Eddie Fisher

Eddie Fisher (1928-2010) was a typically 1950s heartthrob singer of novelty pop songs such as Dungaree Doll, and the above Lady of Spain, which scored big time on the top 40. The pulsating plush arrangements of Hugo Winter­halter (1909-1973) helped immensely with Fisher’s musical success.

Fisher was first married to singer/actress Debbie Reynolds before leaving her to marry Elizabeth Taylor, who in turn would leave him to marry Richard Burton. His career started to tank during the 1960s while his and Reynolds’s daughter, actress Carrie Fisher refused to speak to her father for over 30 years.

In his autobiography, Fisher pays tribute to his Music Director Hugo Winterhalter and tells sadly of the older man losing his will to live after his son Hugo Junior is killed in 1969 while serving in Vietnam. He also collaborated during the less commercially successful ‘60s in a musically very good album for RCA Victor with the phenomenal arranger Nelson Riddle.

Jimmy Dorsey

Jimmy Dorsey

Jimmy Dorsey – Charley, My Boy; and Johnson Rag. Columbia 38649, ten-inch 78, recorded 1949.

In 1949, clarinettist Jimmy Dorsey (1904-1957) assembled a very good group of studio musicians, including Jack Teagarden’s younger brother Charlie on trumpet and pianist Dick Cary, and recorded several captivating Dixieland tunes for Columbia which were quite the contrast to his earlier Decca discs of mostly lyrical and sometimes bland music from the Big Band years (Younger brother Tommy’s records for Victor with the likes of Frank Sinatra, Jo Stafford , Buddy Rich and others were much more musically interesting.).

REVIEW POTPOURRI: Cultural Icons and Historic Recordings

Peter Catesby Peter Cates

Sir Arthur Bryant

Sir Arthur Bryant

English historian Sir Arthur Bryant (1899-1985) was a principal of the Cambridge School of Arts, Crafts and Technology from 1923 to 1926 and raised its student body from 300 to 2,000.

His books were admired by former Prime Ministers Winston Churchill, Harold Wilson, Margaret Thatcher and others and became best sellers because of their narrative readability. The Age of Elegance: 1812-1822, from 1950, has a notable example of Bryant’s gift for entertaining vignettes in his sketch of Napoleon Bonaparte’s Foreign Minister, former Priest and notorious sleazeball Charles Talleyrand (1754-1838):

“Few people liked Talleyrand. Napoleon once described him as filth in silk stockings. He was the most consistent crook of his age. For a quarter of a century, through storm and terror , he had lived, survived, and triumphed by his wits. There were few crimes, including incest, of which he was not believed guilty. No one who saw his dirty, crafty, powdered face, with its half-closed eyes, villainous mouth, and slobbering, darting tongue, was left in any doubt as to the manner of man he was.”

He also described the French people of Napoleon’s time as “half monkey and half tiger.”

Unfortunately, Bryant was a Nazi sympathizer and wrote an introduction to a 1939 English translation of Mein Kampff in which he praised Adolf Hitler’s leadership qualities.

James Maguire

James Maguire

James Maguire’s 2006 Impresario is a biography of the most successful TV variety show host in American history, Ed Sullivan (1901-1974), whose program was seen every Sunday night from 1948 to 1971.

The guests who achieved the highest ratings for the Ed Sullivan Show were – who else? – Elvis Presley on September 9, and October 28, 1956, and the Beatles on February 9, 1964. With respect to Elvis’s gyrating hips, Maguire writes, “While his records flew off the shelves, letters of protest poured into newspapers and television stations across the country.”

The Bookshop

A 2024 history The Bookshop has chapters on several bookstores and the ups and downs of the business in competition with the insidious Jeff Bezos and his Amazon.

One chapter is on New York City’s Strand Bookstore which occupies all four sides of a block. Its founder Benjamin Bass was arrested in 1939 for selling 150 stolen copies of a law book but claimed he was innocent. After a friend testified on his behalf, the judge dismissed the case.

Bass confided to the friend as they left the courtroom, “After you finished talking, I had almost convinced myself that I hadn’t known that those were stolen.”

* * * * * *

Offenbach: Apache Dance; Serradell La Golondrina. Nathaniel Shilkret conducting the Victor Salon Orchestra. Victor 21055, ten inch 78, recorded 1926-27.

Shilkret’s dozens of charming shellacs which ranged from classical composers to dance music include this early example of crossover music – the Apache Dance by French composer Jacques Offenbach and side two’s very popular Mexican love song La Golondrina.

* * * * * *

Rossini/Respighi: La Boutique Fantasque; Ibert: Divertissement; and Piston: The Incredible Flutist. Arthur Fiedler conducting the Boston Pops. RCA Victor Red Seal LM-2084, 12-inch LP, recorded 1956.

The three compositions here are examples of classical music not taking itself so seriously. Ottorino Respighi (1879-1936) was best known for the Pines of Rome, Fountains of Rome and Roman Festivals which are massive monumental orchestral showpiece demanding more than 100 musicians.

La Boutique Fantasque is a collection of Rossini’s miniatures which Respighi orchestrated with exquisite results.

* * * * * *

Jacques Ibert (1890-1962) composed the witty Divertissement as incidental music for a French play during the 1920s. Since then it’s stood on its own as a boisterous romp for Orchestra and makes fun of Mendelssohn’s Wedding March.

Born in Rockland, Maine, Walter Piston (1894-1976) composed the Incredible Flutist in 1938, its world premiere conducted by Arthur Fiedler at a Pops concert that year.

Fiedler recorded the piece not long after its world premiere on Victor 78s and redid it in 1956. The score depicts a nighttime invasion of a quiet village by a traveling circus.

Piston’s grandfather Antonio Pistone emigrated from Genoa, Italy, to Maine and changed his name to Anthony Piston.

* * * * * *

Bruch: Violin Concerto #1 – Yehudi Menuhin, violin, with Pierre Monteux conducting the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra. Victor Red Seal DM-1023, three 12-inch 78s, recorded 1945.

German composer Max Bruch (1838-1920) was best known for his Scottish Fantasy for violin and orchestra; the Kol Nidrei for cello and orchestra and this very beautiful 1st Violin Concerto. In their 1945 collaboration, England’s Yehudi Menuhin and Hancock Maine’s summer resident Pierre Monteux achieved a very powerful and rapturous performance in which one truly sensed the violinist and Maestro in full accord with each other.

* * * * * *

A 1941 movie, The Devil and Daniel Webster, has Walter Huston (1883-1950) portraying Old Scratch himself offering an impoverished New Hampshire farmer, Jaber Stone, seven years of good luck for his soul. When the seven years are running out, Stone runs to Daniel Webster to plead his case.

James Craig (1912-1985) did good work as Stone, Edward Arnold (1890-1956) was a decently eloquent Daniel Webster, while Walter Huston almost stole the show with his extraordinarily built up characterization of Scratch from the folksy stranger chewing on a carrot through the laughing reminder to Stone that payment is due soon and in a split second changing the laughing smile to a stone cold frown via which he intends to collect.

A couple of items relating to the original 1936 short story by Stephen Vincent Benet (1898-1943):

The story mentions that Webster wrestles every morning with his ram Goliath. At the end of the story after Webster rescues Stone from having to pay his debt, Old Scratch was never seen again in New Hampshire. Not so sure about Massachusetts.

REVIEW POTPOURRI: Patti Page; The Accountant

Patti Page

Peter Catesby Peter Cates

Patti Page

Patti Page – Because Him is a Baby; Goodbye Charlie; Mercury 71510, seven-inch vinyl 45, recorded 1959.

Patti Page (1927-2013), along with Doris Day (1922-2019), were two fabulous golden girls of 1950s pop music in combining outstanding musical and commercial success in pop singing (Time and space limits me from naming several other personal favorites).

Born Clara Ann Fowler, in Oklahoma, one of her first musical gigs came at the age of 18 in her native state on a 15-minute local radio show sponsored by the Page Milk Company – hence her stage name. During the late ‘40s, she sang with a band in Chicago led by Benny Goodman who gave Peggy Lee a jumpstart in her career.

The windy city was also the home of Mercury Records where Page would record for over ten years. How Much is that Doggie in the Window; and The Old Cape Cod were huge hits during her Mercury years.

Interestingly, this 1959 coupling is one of Miss Page’s rarer records. The two songs combine her gifts for beautiful contralto singing and songs dealing with immature adults – (Because Him is a Baby) – and disloyal lovers — (Goodbye Charlie) – who cause chaos, themes similar to her 1951 megahit Tennessee Waltz, where “My friend stole my sweetheart from me.” (Around the same year, comedy band leader Spike Jones did his own Tennessee Waltz utilizing a chorus of cackling old ladies.).

The arrangements on the 1959 disc were imaginative ones by the gifted Pete Rugolo (1915-2011) with lovely woodwind and brass details. He did phenomenal scorings for the progressive big band jazz leader Stan Kenton whose music making was otherwise quite the distance from that of Miss Page.

In 1962, she appeared in the comedy film Boys Night Out with James Garner and Kim Novak and lent considerable charm to her role as a suburban wife.

The Accountant

During two successive evenings, I viewed the 2016 suspense film The Accountant and the 2025 The Accountant 2, starring Ben Afleck, as an autistic genius level accountant and highly lethal assassin of bad people, Christian Wolff.

Two films of his I have seen previously are the 2002 thriller Changing Lanes with Samuel L. Jackson and Amanda Peet; and the 2006 Hollywoodland in which Afleck portrayed actor George Reeves (1914-1959) who was the star of the justly successful TV series, The Adventures of Superman, which ran from 1951 to 1957.

The bio film was quite fascinating in its depiction of Reeves’s struggles with typecasting and Afleck’s facial resemblance to Reeves but at the same time the film was difficult to watch because I was so used to Reeves as Superman and couldn’t accept Afleck’s credibility in the role.

The merits of both Accountant films are of different degrees. The 2016 film has much in the blood and gore and narrow escapes which sustains interest at that level. The remake of 9 years later, while still dealing with highly dangerous criminals, has a much more nuanced development of character in Christian Wolff’s confronting of issues in his personal life and relationships. The visibly late middle aging of Ben Afleck, now 53 years old, is brought very consummately to bear in his portrayal of Wolff and his relationship with his younger brother Braxton, aptly portrayed by Jon Bernthal, from whom Christian was estranged for several years; Braxton is also a similarly lethal killer who doesn’t quite have the moral qualms of Christian.

However, he is immensely helpful to Christian as they reconcile and head to a remote Mexican compound to rescue several dozen children kidnapped by traffickers who now plan to massacre them for purposes of expediency.

Good supporting roles were provided by Portland native Anna Kendrick and John Lithgow in the 2016 film and J.K. Simmons in both 2016 and the remake.

***

Donizetti: La Favorita – Una vergine (Like an Angel); Florencio Constantino, tenor; Victor Red Seal 64090, ten-inch one-sided acoustic shellac disc, recorded May 22nd, 1907.

Tenor Florencio Constantino (1869-1919) didn’t have the pipes of Enrico Caruso but he did have a lovely lyrical high, middle and low register and gave a very nice performance of this aria. He had a solid career until a 1917 lawsuit resulting in a nervous breakdown led to his early death in a Mexico City hospital.

***

Jimmy Dorsey – Holiday for Strings; and Ohio; Decca 18593, ten inch 78, recorded 1944.

Clarinettist/bandleader Jimmy Dorsey (1904-1957) and older brother of Tommy Dorsey (1905-1956) recorded a very jazz swing rendition of David Rose’s famous Holiday for Strings and brought a captivating scoring for the brass section to a piece of music that is still crappy.

Side 2’s Ohio is a decent pop standard from the World War II years and featured in a 1944 musical, Four Jills in a Jeep.

Jimmy’s own records didn’t quite have the vibrant beauty of Tommy’s but he did have the immensely enjoyable singer Kitty Kallen, unfortunately not featured here.

REVIEW POTPOURRI: Andy Williams, Winifred Atwell, Shostakovich, Perry Mason

Peter Catesby Peter Cates

Andy Williams

Andy Williams: Hopeless; The Peking Theme (So Little Time). Columbia 4-42784, seven inch 45 disc, recorded 1963.

Andy Williams

My first exposure to Andy Williams (1927-2012) came from his late ‘50s Cadence 45, The Hawaiian Wedding Song, a tune that my eight-year-old ears enjoyed a lot – however, during those years, Pat Boone was still my favorite singer.

In 1963, Williams’s two deservedly successful Columbia LPs, Moon River; and Days of Wine and Roses were released and gifted to me, respectively, by my maternal grandparents and Mom. Both title songs were composed by the superb team of Johnny Mercer and Henry Mancini, the rest of the albums consisting of Great American Songbook standards – Can’t Get Used to Losing You, Maria, The Second Time Around, It’s a Most Unusual Day, Exactly Like You, It Might as Well Be Spring, etc.

The arrangements of Robert Mersey (1917-1994) were wondrously typical of those he did for albums of teen idol Bobby Vinton (who just celebrated his 90th birthday this past April 16 and is most remembered for Roses are Red, My Love; and She Wore Blue Velvet ); and jazz singer Mel Torme’s That’s Life.

Like Perry Como, Al Martino, Jerry Vale, Ed Ames, Jack Jones, Steve Lawrence and Eydie Gorme, Andy Williams personified the easy listening style of singing that peaked during the Eisenhower and Kennedy years and he succeeded because he was dang good. The above two selections are forgettable yet charming trifles and are superbly rendered by the Williams/Mercey team; I am now quite curious about the film 55 Days at Peking mentioned as the source for side two’s So Little Time.

During the early ‘80s, Williams did a live outdoor holiday special in New York City in which he is directed to the passenger seat of a motorcycle, its driver being then-NYC Mayor Ed Koch.

Winifred Atwell

Winifred Atwell, pianist, with Frank Chacksfield and his Orchestra – The Black Mask Waltz; and Song of the Sea (Cancion del Mar). London 1544, ten-inch 78 disc, recorded mid-1950s.

Winifred Atwell

When it came to post World War II easy listening, the Brits more than held their own. The Decca/London label signed up some of the best pop orchestra arrangers including Mantovani, Stanley Black, the Canadian Robert Farnon and Frank Chacksfield, who scored his own megahit with the very atmospheric 1953 Ebb Tide.

The above 78 features Chacksfield’s very tastefully lush and evocative collaborations with pianist Winifred Atwell (1910-1983), a native of Trinidad who performed classical and semi-classical selections but achieved even greater fame with honky tonk, ragtime and boogie woogie records that were hits during the ‘50s.

The Black Mask Waltz and Song of the Sea, with its slightly tangoish dance rhythms, are very engaging examples of orchestral easy listening bordering on semi-classical.

Miss Atwell recorded the Grieg Piano Concerto in 1954 that can be heard on YouTube.

Shostakovich

In the 1943 edition of the Music Lover’s Handbook, there is an essay on Shostakovich’s 5th Symphony by a Russian musicologist Grigori Schneerson (1901-1982). Bearing in mind that this Symphony was completed in 1937 when Stalin’s reign of terror was reaching frightening heights with mass arrests, bogus trials and summary executions, the Symphony met with acclaim and most likely saved Shostakovich’s life (an opera, Lady Macbeth, had Stalin leaving the theater in a rage during its premiere in 1934.)

Schneerson wrote:

“In the Western World, the object of the avant-garde is presumably the overthrow of old artistic foundations, the breaking-out in ‘new paths,’ however meaningless and at any cost. For us in the Soviet [Union], however, the avant-garde is held to express progressive ideas only when it talks to the people in a new, powerful, and intelligible language. The demands of the wide masses of people, their artistic tastes, grow from day to day. The ‘advanced’ composer is therefore one who plunges into the social currents swirling around him, and with his creative work serves the progress of humankind. “

This is the kind of gibberish that Stalin’s hacks were spinning constantly in the name of the “wide masses of people…humankind”. 1943 was also the year that FDR, Churchill and Stalin met at Tehran in Iran to form an alignment of forces against Hitler and Mussolini, a “friendship” that lasted until around 1946 when Stalin began double-crossing the U.S. on everything he agreed to at Tehran, Yalta, in February, 1945 and Potsdam in 1946. Thus this essay may have been published in 1943 without any vetting because of this new Soviet/American relationship.

For all the circumstances surrounding the Shostakovich 5th, it remains a 20th century masterpiece with several fabulous recordings from such conductors as Dimitri Mitropoulos, Leonard Bernstein, Yevgeni Mravinsky, Semyon Bychkov and several others, also accessible on YouTube.

Department Q

A newly-streamed Netflix series of nine episodes already available for viewing, Department Q, is highly recommended for its suspense, intelligently scripted dialog, phenomenal acting and captivating sub-plots. More in a later column as I have only reached episode 4.

Perry Mason novel

Erle Stanley Gardner

In the Foreword to a 1969 Perry Mason novel, The Case of the Fabulous Fake, author Erle Stanley Gardner mentions a noted forensics investigator in California and inserts a quote from him:

“This is the space age, but crime-fighting has not kept pace with other scientific developments since World War II. Any time the American people are ready to give the problem sufficient attention and priority, we can raise the present ‘solved’ and ‘conviction’ rates from maybe 10 percent to 90 percent. When it becomes unprofitable for a criminal to commit a crime, he’s going to think twice or three times about doing it. When he knows the odds are nine to one that he’s going to get caught and going to jail, crime will lose a lot of its appeal. But until that happens, why shouldn’t people continue to commit crimes? It’s quite a profitable trade!”

During the subsequent 1970s in cities all across the U.S., the crime rate skyrocketed. By the 21st century, forensics had advanced, not to mention DNA, and increased the conviction rates but there are still dozens of unsolved cold cases.

Meanwhile the Perry Mason novels are very entertaining, along with the nine seasons of the CBS television series starring Raymond Burr.

REVIEW POTPOURRI: Aaron Copland, Gloria Lynne

by Peter Cates

Aaron Copland

Aaron Copland – Music for the Theatre Suite; Howard Hanson conducting the Eastman-Rochester Symphony Orchestra; Victor Red Seal M-744, three 12-inch 78s, recorded 1940.

Aaron Copland

Aaron Copland (1900-1990) completed his Music for the Theatre in 1925 during the summer months at New Hamp­shire’s Mac­Dowell Colony for the Arts. It is a beautifully introspective work with lovely passages for each section of the orchestra.

Howard Hanson (1896-1981) was Director of the Eastman School of Music at the University of Rochester from 1924 to 1964, a noted composer himself and an outstanding conductor of 20th century American music. This 1940 recording, for my taste, is even better performance-wise than the 1960s stereo recording of Leonard Bernstein and the New York Philharmonic, despite that younger conductor’s close friendship with Copland, because of Bernstein’s over-emotional approach and lack of sensitivity to this music’s quieter moments.

The Hanson 78s can be heard at Archive.org on the Internet.

Gloria Lynne

Gloria Lynne – He Needs Me; Everest LPBR-5128, 12-inch LP, recorded 1961.

Singer Gloria Lynne (1929-2013) emerged during the 1950s and ’60s when other fine African-American vocalists such as Dinah Washington, Della Reese, Sarah Vaughan, Nancy Wilson, Aretha Franklin, Dionne Warwick were achieving much deserved success in jazz and pop music. Lynne had a uniquely lyrical delicacy to her voice similar to that of Nancy Wilson.

Her renditions of I Thought About You, The Lamp is Low, If You Love Me and others on this 1961 Everest album conveyed this quality nicely, with the superb arrangements of Jimmy Jones and his Orchestra.

Two Sibelius 78s:

Finlandia – Artur Rodzinski conducting the Cleveland Orchestra; Columbia Masterworks 11178, 12-inch 78, recorded 1940.

Swan of Tuonela – Leopold Stokowski conducting the Phildelphia Orchestra; Victor Red Seal 7380, 12-inch 78, recorded 1937.

Finland’s still justifiably greatest composer Jean Sibelius (1865-1957), according to the great Maestro Eugene Ormandy who visited with him during an early 1950s concert tour of the Philadelphia Orchestra in Scandinavia, had shelves of records and a top notch phonograph in his living room.

Castine Maine’s David Hall commented in a 1967 Stereo Review piece that the music of the Finn in its celebration of the rocky coast, woods and meadows reminded him of the Penobscot Bay area encompassing Deer Isle, Blue Hill and, of course, Hall’s own favorite village. I once asked if he and the composer ever met; the reply: “I once had the opportunity but chickened out!”

Artur Rodzinski conducted a joyously bristling performance of Finlandia which has become Finland’s own national anthem equivalent of the Star Spangled Banner. In the late ‘50s, Ormandy recorded Finlandia with his Philadelphians and the Mormon Tabernacle Choir which has been my own favorite for more than 60 years.

In 1936, Leopold Stokowski invited Eugene Ormandy to be his co-conductor in Philadelphia, as he admired what Ormandy was achieving with the Minneapolis Symphony . In 1938, Stokowski resigned.

The 1937 Victor shellac featuring Stoky’s interpretive magic in Sibelius’s Swan of Tuonela is well worth hearing via YouTube, especially for the hauntingly eloquent English horn.

Stokowski later rerecorded the Swan with a studio orchestra for Victor and hired Mitch Miller, then one of the finest players of both the oboe and English horn in the country and later more famous for the Sing Along LPs on Columbia Records.

Some more about Sibelius:

The composer told violinist Yehudi Menuhin that Bela Bartok was his favorite 20th century composer.

When German pianist Wilhelm Kempff visited Sibelius, he played the Hammerklavier Sonata which was the composer’s favorite Beethoven piece.

Enrico Caruso

Enrico Caruso

The widow of legendary tenor Enrico Caruso (1873-1921), Dorothy Caruso published a biography of her husband in 1945, titled simply Enrico Caruso His Life and Death.

Although a native New Yorker, she lived much of her adult life in France and Italy. During the late 1930s, she did humanitarian relief work in the Maritime Alps feeding and clothing impoverished families.

In the conclusion to her husband’s biography, Mrs. Caruso wrote:

“When I returned to this country [in 1942] I found that Enrico was not forgotten but living as if he had never died. Twenty-five years is a long time [the couple eloped in 1917] but my memory of him is as clear as if he had left me an hour ago. With every word I wrote he walked into the room. The more I wrote, the more clear those years became.

“I never reread his letters after his death. I never looked at them until I began the book and realized that they were the best illustration of his thought. Because he was such a silent man and thought before he spoke, I think I have remembered everything he said.”

Caruso’s unfailingly down to earth personality is conveyed in an exchange with his good friend John McCormack. When the Irish tenor greeted him with “How’s the world’s greatest tenor this morning?”, Caruso replied, “I didn’t know you were now a baritone.”

With his earnings, Caruso was a secret pal to many. A cleaning lady at the Met Opera was overheard telling a friend that her husband had fallen off a scaffolding and she didn’t know how she would be able to support their family with several children. She found a wad of hundred dollar bills in her winter coat.

REVIEW POTPOURRI: These were our songs

Peter Catesby Peter Cates

These were our songs

These Were Our Songs – The Early ‘30s; Reader’s Digest KRB 187/A2, released 1989.

This cassette contains beautifully done transfers from 28 vintage 78 sides, recorded on the Victor label during the early 1930s of classics from the Great American Songbook.

Its contents –

Maurice Chevalier, Mimi; and Walkin’ My Baby Back Home.
Bing Crosby– Where the Blue of the Night Meets the Gold of the Day; Sweet and Lovely; and I Surrender, Dear.
Fred Astaire, Night and Day.
Paul Whiteman – Willow Weep for Me.
Jeannette MacDonald – One Hour with You; and Beyond the Blue Horizon.
Russ Columbo – All of Me; and I Don’t Know Why.
The Mills Brothers – Tiger Rag.
Cab Calloway – Minnie the Moocher.
Wayne King – Star Dust; and Dream a Little Dream of Me.
Fred Waring – Dancing in the Dark; I Found a Million-Dollar Baby (in a Five and Ten Cent Store); and Little White Lies.
University of Maine’s own Rudy Vallee – Would You Like to Take a Walk?
Ted Black – Love Letters in the Sand.
Harry Richman – On the Sunny Side of the Street.
The High Hatters – Get Happy.
Duke Ellington – Three Little Words.
Leo Reisman – Paradise; Sing Something Simple; Body and Soul; and Happy Days are Here Again.
A majestic lament concluding Side 2, Ben Bernie – It’s a Lonesome Old Town (When You’re Not Around).

Tape 2 is listed on the container, indicating that this was part of a set titled These Were Our Songs, and is the only one I own. Having previously written of the joys still to be found listening to scratchy old 78s, I also own hundreds of such discs including the fragile dusty black label Victors of other selections by several of the artists listed here – Leo Reisman, Duke Ellington, the High Hatters, Fred Waring, Jeannette MacDonald with and without Nelson Eddy (on both the Victor black label and Red Seals) and huge piles of Paul Whiteman.

And each performance here is a gem in the best old-fashioned sense of the word.

Russ Columbo was achieving much success with his films, radio shows and records and was an influence on the singing of Bing Crosby and Perry Como when, during a September, 1934, visit to a friend’s house in Los Angeles, the two men were examining an antique pistol. It accidentally fired a bullet which ricocheted off the wall and hit Columbo in the eye. He was rushed to a nearby hospital where surgeons tried unsuccessfully to remove the bullet and died six hours later. He was only 26.

Astor Piazzolla

Astor Piazzolla – Maria de Buenos Aires; Gidon Kremer with small ensemble of singers and instrumentalists. Teldec 3984-20632-2, recorded 1998, two cds.

Astor Piazzolla

Argentine composer Astor Piazzolla (1921-1992) brought the tango rhythms, along with elements of jazz and classical music, into this 1968 operetta of just over 90 minutes and a quite exhilarating listening experience. In addition to a quartet of strings, a percussionist, a flutist and a pianist, the music requires a chorus of about 15 and 3 soloists. Finally the central instrument is the bandoneon, which looks like a concertina, sounds like a combination of pump organ, harmonica and accordion, the results being quite beautiful, and always associated with tango dance music.

A few different performances of the operetta exist on YouTube.

Hans Swarowsky

Mahler 3rd Symphony – Hans Swarowsky conducting the Berlin Radio Symphony, January 21, 1963, broadcast.

Hans Swarowsky

Austrian conductor Hans Swarowsky (1899-1975) was more well known as the teacher of conductors Zubin Mehta and Claudio Abbado but did record a large number of composers including Gustav Mahler.

Mahler’s 3rd is the longest of his Nine Symphonies, at just over 85 minutes.

This burnt CD set, courtesy of a friend, has Swarowsky conducting a very spirited performance of its six movements; during his career, Swarowsky was unfairly dismissed as average or worse by critics who ranted that the Maestro should confine himself to the classroom.

I own numerous LPs of Swarowsky conducting Brahms, Bruckner, Mozart, Tchaikovsky, Wagner etc., and found them very enjoyable on their own terms.

A bonus on this set is Swarowsky collaborating in a 1956 Vienna State Opera Orchestra recording with pianist Eduard Mrazek in a very engaging Brahms 2nd Piano Concerto.

Stan Kenton

Stan Kenton – Dynaflow; Tortillas and Beans; Capitol F1535, recorded 1951.

Stan Kenton

I have always enjoyed Stan Kenton’s records featuring his wild big band arrangements with irregular rhythms and festive brass sonorities. These two sides feature a feisty ins­trumental Dyna­flow and Tortillas and Beans, a tongue in cheek vocal duet by Eddie Gomez and Ray Wetzel, who composed both selections.

 

 

 

 

 

 

.

REVIEW POTPOURRI: Johannes Brahms

Peter Catesby Peter Cates

Johannes Brahms

Brahms Symphony 1 – Hermann Scherchen conducting the Vienna State Opera Orchestra; Classaphonic-CL-68. 12 inch lp, recorded mid to late 50s.

Johannes Brahms

Johannes Brahms was already sketching a First Symphony in 1853 as his friend Robert Schumann was praising the then young composer as the great new hope in music who would provide “yet more wondrous glimpses into the mysteries of the world of the spirit.” The sketches eventually grew into the magnificent First Piano Concerto in 1857.

Another 19 years elapsed when Brahms presented his First Symphony in its 1876 World Premiere in a rural town in Germany where several friends were eagerly awaiting its performance.

The Symphony met with resounding success and has been performed and recorded countless times since then, being still a favorite with audiences. Having already admitted in earlier columns that Brahms has been my favorite composer for decades, I am certainly biased in finding things to enjoy in this recording, as with batches of other Brahms 1sts in my collection, whether good, bad or indifferent.

Hermann Scherchen conducted a performance that was uniquely captivating for its foreboding grandeur in the opening movement, its sweet sentiment in the second movement, the dancing, slightly melancholy delicacy in the 3rd movement and the jubilation in the concluding 4th movement. Scherchen also speeded up tempos even more quickly than Leonard Bernstein and Eugen Jochum on their justly acclaimed recordings towards the end of the 4th Finale- he could be perverse with tempos and phrasing- but this recording ended up being such a pleasure that I have played it at least 4 times since yesterday.

John Josselyn

John Josselyn

The adventurous English aristocrat John Josselyn (1608-1675) traveled to New England twice, 1638 and 1663, and his massively detailed An Account of Two Voyages to New-England provided ground breaking research on animals, plants and native American life.

An example – he wrote interestingly about the homes in tribal villages, as conveyed in the following sentence:

“Their houses which they call Wigwams, are built with Poles pitched into the ground of a round form for most part, sometimes square, they bind down the tops of their poles, leaving a hole for smoke to go out at, the rest they cover with the bark of trees, and line the inside of their Wigwams with mats made of rushes painted with several colors, one good post they set up in the middle that reaches to the hole in the top, with a staff across before it at a convenient height, they knock in a pin on which they hang their Kettle, beneath that they set up a broad stone for a back which keepeth the post from burning; round by the walls they spread their mats and skins where the men sleep whilst the women dress their victuals, they have commonly two doors, one opening to the South, the other to the North, and according as the wind sits, they close up one door with bark and hang a Dears skin or the like before the other.”

Josselyn also told tall tales about seeing pre-historic creatures such as sea lions and serpents and spotting a mermaid or two. In addition, he portrayed the harsh deadly New England landscape and climate as heaven on earth.

There is an anecdote where he started chewing a wasp’s nest, thinking it was a pineapple. His face became so swollen and disfigured that his friends recognized him only by his clothes.

Josselyn’s second visit in 1663 lasted several years until he eventually returned to England where he first wrote New-England Rareties Discovered in 1672 and An Account two years later.

In 1675 John Josselyn died at the age of 67, fulfilling a French proverb he lived by – “Travail where thou canst, but dye where thou oughtest, that is, in thine own Countrey.”

D.L. Miller

A few years ago, I wrote about the 99 cent Somerset/Stereo Fidelity LPs created by the Pennsylvania businessman D.L. Miller back in 1957. In addition to the classical recording sessions he brokered with such orchestras as the London and Hamburg Philharmonics, Miller created an immense and very profitable catalog of LPs by the 101 Strings which were inevitably transferred to cassettes and CDs. Three particular titles- With Love from London, Symphony for Lovers and Gypsy Campfires – were part of my parents otherwise small record collection.

Nelson Riddle conducted the 101 Strings in one of their finest recordings, one I’ve played numerous times.

Miller sold the label to an English businessman who changed its name to Alshire. A cassette release, The Best of 101 Strings (Alshire, ALSC-5373), features a dozen rhythmically pulsating arrangements of such pop staples as Moon River, I Left My Heart In San Francisco, The Way We Were, Lara’s Theme from Doctor Zhivago, etc.

* * * * * *

I highly recommend the recently streamed film Conclave, which depicts the secret proceedings at Vatican City as the Cardinals are choosing a new Pope. Ralph Fiennes heads a superb cast as the chief moderator of the proceedings.

REVIEW POTPOURRI: Maria Duenas

Peter Catesby Peter Cates

Maria Duenas

Lalo: Symphonie Espagnole – violinist Maria Duenas with Mihhail Gerts conducting the Estonian National Orchestra, 2019 concert video on YouTube.

Maria Duenas

Spanish violinist Maria Duenas, now 22, has already landed a recording contract with Deutsche Grammophon and won several first prizes at violin competitions around the world since the age of 17. She has cited her favorite violinists, Jascha Heifetz, Yehudi Menuhin and David Oistrakh, as the inspiration for developing her own style expressing concern about too many other violinists sounding too much alike, a sentiment I agree with.

Some time ago, I viewed a YouTube of her performing Max Bruch’s Violin Concerto and found it engaging enough to sit through the entire performance yet not particularly moving.

Still, for some mysterious reason, I got curious enough to view this performance of the Symphonie Espagnole by French composer Edouard Lalo (1823-1892) as this very captivating showpiece has grown on me more and more in recent years. (When Tchaikovsky got access to the manuscript in 1878 and played through it on the piano, he was inspired enough to compose his own Violin Concerto.).

Again and most unfortunately Duenas’s playing of this piece did not leave me wanting more. She phrased the notes and bars nicely enough (She omitted movements three and four of a five movement piece; the jump from the jubilant opening two movements to the jubilant Finale without the contrasting calm lyricism of three and four was jarring) and conveyed endearing stage presence but the overall interpretation didn’t take fire.

A plus here, however, was watching the focused musicians who gave their all, unlike so many players in more well known orchestras who seem to be merely going through the motions in the umpteenth performance of a given piece. The Estonian National Orchestra is another example of the excitement and commitment to be seen among the symphony orchestras now gaining fame in the post Iron Curtain eastern Europe, others being the Radio Orchestras of Bucharest, Ljubljana, Bratislava etc.

As for Miss Duenas, I feel that, because of her expressed commitment to developing her own style, she may remain a violinist worth watching.

My favorite recordings of the Lalo Symphonie Espagnole are the two collaborations of Isaac Stern with Eugene Ormandy and the Philadelphia Orchestra on Columbia Masterworks LPs from 1955 and 1965 and presumably available also on YouTube. Stern is not otherwise among my top five or even ten favorite violinists but he really had this music thoroughly nailed down while Ormandy was always a masterful accompanist in Concertos.

Both of the above LPs also contain eloquent performances of the Bruch Violin Concerto.

Kansas City Confidential

John Payne

A most entertaining 1952 Film Noir classic, imbued with 1950s time warp atmosphere, intelligence, lack of predictability and fascinating character development is Kansas City Confi­dential starring John Payne as the protagonist and Jack Elam and Lee Van Cleef as two armored truck robbers. All three actors did superb work in their roles and conveyed formidable presence.

Casino Dance Orchestra

Casino Dance Orchestra – Wonderful One; Good-Night. Perfect 14117, ten-inch 78, recorded circa 1923-24.

The Casino Dance Orchestra was a pseudonym for several dance orchestras making records during the 1920s. Whoever the musicians on this shellac were, they were very gifted ones.

The two selections – the particularly exquisite Wonderful One composed by the well-known dance band leader Paul Whiteman and his chief arranger Ferde Grofe, most renowned for his own Grand Canyon Suite; and the throwaway yet charming Good-Night on side two – were given performances in which the saxophones, trombones and muted trumpets blended beautifully while the banjo and piano provided pulsating rhythms.

One of the best discs to be heard from the dime store Perfect label.